About Us

Welcome to the Florida Keys Rental Store

Imagine a place where the waters are clear, clean, and full of beautiful sea life, where a relaxing stroll down the main thoroughfare was not interrupted by the sound of traffic. A place where Sportsfishing, Backcountry fishing, and scuba diving were all within a short distance from world-class dining featuring fresh from the dock seafood as well as other chef-prepared culinary favorites. All of this can be found in the Florida Keys, and the heart of it all is in Islamorada and Key Largo. The Florida Keys Rental Store is proud to be part of this unique and beautiful community, helping vacation seekers find accommodations and plan vacations for over a decade.

Known as the “American Caribbean” by some and “paradise” by almost all who visit and live here, The Florida Keys has the feel of a quaint seaside village with a laid-back vibe, taking you worlds away from everyday cares. Whether you start your day taking in the sunrise on an oceanfront veranda or heading out on the water for an adventure, the Florida Keys has something to offer everyone. The Florida Keys Rental Store knows that our island lifestyle is just as important as your accommodations and we are prepared to match you to the right property to fit your vacation needs.

We provide the ultimate luxury in private vacation home rentals and enhance your stay with professional personal services. Specializing in Florida Keys vacation rental homes in Key Largo and Islamorada in the Upper Florida Keys. Our exquisite properties offer breathtaking ocean views, gorgeous beachfront locations, and the finest amenities that include swimming pools, spas, and close proximity to fishing, shopping, and world-class dining.

Let Us Fulfill Your Perfect Vacation Wishes


The Florida Keys Rental Store is dedicated to providing you with peace of mind. Specializing in finer homes, we offer one of the most diverse selections of properties throughout the Upper Keys area, allowing us to make the best “match” between renters and owners. You will know that your property is professionally marketed and maintained. You will have the comfort of knowing that your property is in good hands in your absence since at The Florida Keys Rental Store, we treat each of our properties as if it were our own.

Established in the 1980s, the Florida Keys Rental Store is the Residential Property Management division of American Caribbean Real Estate, a proven leader in Florida Keys real estate. American Caribbean Real Estate is the largest independently owned real estate company in the Upper Keys and is the exclusive Florida Keys affiliate of Christie’s International Real Estate.

The Florida Keys Rental Store believes the strength of a team is needed to attend to the 24/7 demand of rental operations. Our Property Management Team is highly experienced and prides itself on consistent reliable service to both owners and vacationing customers. Our staff and leaders have in excess of 20 years of residential experience in the Keys.

About The Florida Keys

Our tropical paradise is a community of islands, connected to one another by a series of bridges. At the top of the Keys, nearest to the mainland, you’ll find Key Largo. At the end, 106 miles southwest, is Key West, jutting out in the Atlantic Ocean a mere 90 miles from Cuba. Along the way,
you’ll find the communities of Tavernier, Islamorada – known as the sportfishing capital of the world, Marathon – known as the heart of the Keys, and Big Pine – home to the diminutive Key Deer.

Wherever you make your year ’round residence, chances are the weather is better here in the Keys on any given day. This is true even on a Summer’s day. At the peak of Summer, the average high is 89 degrees, with our surrounding waters offering cooling breezes.

As for activities, there are plenty. Naturally, with the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic Ocean as our backyard, a lot of activities focus their attention on the water. The coral reef is famous for its abundance of marine life. Whether your pleasure is snorkeling or SCUBA diving, there are sites that are ideally suited for each.

The Keys’ waters offer some of the best sport fishing in the country. Numerous tournaments are offered all year throughout the Keys and attract anglers from all over the world. All in all, the Florida Keys are a wonderful place to vacation, be it a week, or more this is a true getaway from the rest of the world.